Level Up Careers

Level Up Careers

Stop saying "we" in interviews

The Random Recruiter's avatar
The Random Recruiter
Jun 04, 2026
∙ Paid

Before we begin:

  1. Make sure to check out my new site (work in progress)

    https://getvibeprep.com/

  2. Resume and linkedin reviews for all new founding members are here to stay!


In This Issue

  • The debrief that sank a candidate I knew was qualified

  • What a hiring manager actually hears when you say “we”

  • Why “we” is the most expensive word in your interview vocabulary

  • The bench problem, and why “we won” tells nobody anything

  • How to find the “I” buried inside every “we”

  • When “we” is the right call, and how not to sound like a liar

  • A 10-minute drill to run before your next interview


Last month I put a backend engineer in front of a VP at a bank. Let’s call him Devin.

He was a strong SWE with a good financial services background.

I knew he was an automatic interview once I got on the phone with him and sent him to the client.

He didn’t get the offer.

Not because he wasn’t qualified. He lost it on language. And I want to walk you through exactly how, because I see this kill candidates every week and almost nobody catches it in time.

The Debrief That Told Me Everything

I called the VP the morning after the panel.

I’ve made this call a few thousand times over ten years, and I can usually tell in the first ten seconds whether I’m getting an offer or a polite no.

This one was a no, and the reason she gave me was the one I dread.

“He seems smart,” she said. “I just couldn’t tell what he actually did.”

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of The Random Recruiter.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 The Random Recruiter · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture